The summer breeze: Chung Chen Sun's artistic footprint in Taiwan
Dr. Liao Hsin-tien, Director-General of the National Museum of History, Taiwan
Prologue
Taiwan is located in the center of the island chain on the west side of the Pacific Ocean, and its geographic location is undoubtedly important. Culturally, it is at a pivotal position: imported with modernism from the American culture at its east, Mainland China culture at its west, Japanese colonial culture at its north, and Austronesian cultural language family at its south. Logically speaking, there should be unobstructed communication in all directions. At present, as far as the author knows, the connection between Southeast Asian culture and Taiwan is the weakest among these four aspects in terms of the art landscape. There are many reasons, including political and economic differences and cultural alienation.
The summer breeze ("Xunfeng" in Chinese) from the south is warm and cool, and it is the most pleasant since it was known in the ancient days. Using it to describe the relationship between Southeast Asian culture and Taiwan in this manner is nothing more than lifelike. By flipping through the pages of art exchange history between Taiwan and Southeast Asia, Chung Chen Sun from Malaysia proved that there had been enthusiastic literary exchanges in the past. In March 2012, Lee Chi-Mao and Chung Chen Sun's joint exhibition "Xunfeng Art Tour" at the National Museum of History (hereinafter referred to as MUSEUM OF HISTORY), combined with art tourism, gave "Xunfeng" a more artistic meaning to it. The author will follow this period of history from the MUSEUM OF HISTORY to find out how pleasant this “summer breeze” was.
Malaysia Art News
In April 1965, the 3rd International Photography Exhibition of the Republic of China was held at the National Gallery of the National Museum of History. Among the participating countries, Malaysia ranked first, followed by Hong Kong, Austria, South Korea, and Germany. In early 1969, Malaysian Chinese Yan Yuying donated the Republic of China gold coins (banknotes issued by the Chinese Revolutionary Party) and Emperor Guangxu’s banknotes to MUSEUM OF HISTORY and they were displayed in the coin chamber. At the end of the same year, the miniature art sculptor Huang Laofen donated three of his works to MUSEUM OF HISTORY and in 1981 he returned to MUSEUM OF HISTORY to hold the "Exhibition of Miniature Art Sculptures" with a total of more than 50 pieces of his works. In 1972, the 9th International Society of Plastic and Audio-Visual Art exhibition was exhibited at the MUSEUM OF HISTORY. Other than the host country, members of the association came from Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Thailand, Singapore, and Brazil. In November 1982, the Malaysian Chinese Cultural Society hosted the Contemporary Chinese Ink Painting Exhibition at the MCA Building in Kuala Lumpur. The 200 pieces of artwork also included the "Formosa Evergreen" painting which was completed at the beginning of that year. In 1996, MUSEUM OF HISTORY organized the "Asia-Pacific Museum Directors Conference", and Malaysia was also one of the invitees. In 1997, Malaysian Chinese Sim Mow Yu won the Executive Yuan National Cultural Award.
These clues tell us that the cultural exchanges between Malaysia and Taiwan are quite close but it was Mr. Chung Chen Sun who really showed the frequent and substantial interactions.
The Art Ambassador
News about Chung Chen Sun was featured in the "Central Daily News" on March 12, 1973, with the headline: "Promoting China-Malaysia Cultural Exchanges, Chung Chen Sun and others will visit China" with a black and white photo. On the same day, "Economic Daily News" also reported: "Malaysian Institute of Art’s Principal Chung Chen Sun, and Director of the Fine Arts Department Tew Nai Tong, arrived in Taipei from Tokyo at 9.30 pm last night." This interview message was published in the 26th issue of "Hsiung Shih Art Monthly": "Mr. Chung Chen Sun, Principal of Malaysian Institute of Art and Professor Tew Nai Tong, the head of the Department of Fine Arts of MIA, came up to visit China on March 11 for four days to meet with Chinese art institutions, galleries, and other facilities in order to promote cultural exchanges between China and Malaysia.". Perhaps because of this connection, the Malaysian art news was covered once again in the "Malaysia Art News" edition in 77th issue (July 1977) "Hsiung Shih Art Monthly": The Truth, Goodness, and Beauty Gallery held an invitational exhibition of watercolor paintings (Tew Nai Tong, Tang Tuck Kan, Qin Yexing, Qin Yecheng, Puah Kim Hai, Le Chek Wen, He Minglin, Chuang Kim Siew, Abdulrashid Hussein), and the art activities of Today Art Gallery and Hilton Gallery. Lastly, there was the news on Chung Chen Sun's accolade:
Mr. Chung Chen Sun, the current principal who founded the "Malaysian Institute of Art", has made a lot of contributions to art education in his country and recently was conferred the PPN title from Malaysia’s supreme head of state. Chung is the first Chinese artist to have received this title.
Hsiung Shih Art Monthly" Issue 82 (December 1977) also published four articles: Malaysian Chinese Cultural Society 77 Exhibition (Organiser Chung Chen Sun, Organising Committee Chairman Choong Kam Kow), 1977 Art Competition, Joint Exhibition of Seven Kuala Lumpur Artists, Malaysia Institute of Art and the Kuala Lumpur College of Art hold annual exhibitions respectively. The monthly focus of this issue was "Tew Nai Tong, the one who is good at watercolor (painting) and sculpture" (author Chuang Kim Siew). At the end of the article, it was mentioned that Chung and Tew were invited by the Ministry of Education to visit Taiwan. In 1979, MUSEUM OF HISTORY held an exhibition of Chinese calligraphy and painting by overseas Chinese artists. Chung Chen Sun participated in the exhibition with "The Happy Moments of Grandparents and Grandchildren" and became one of the five collections in MUSEUM OF HISTORY (the other four are "The Iban", "Let’s Get Really Drunk", "Catching Louse", "The (Music)Movement"). Then, on December 20th of the following year, Principal Chung held a solo exhibition at MUSEUM OF HISTORY, which was regarded as his formal move to let the Taiwan art arena to get to know this Malaysian ink painting artist. "United Daily News" report (1980/12/18):
Chung Chen Sun, the Principal of the Malaysian Institute of Art, visited China yesterday and will preside over the painting exhibition opened at the Nanhai Road History Museum in Taipei on the 20th. Chung Chen Sun is of Meixian, Guangdong descent, and graduated from Nanyang Academy of Fine Arts in his early years. In 1966, he founded the first art college in Malaysia. At present, the school has four departments consisting of pure art, commercial art, interior design, and music. There are more than 400 students, most of which are Chinese. Forty-five-year-old Chung Chen Sun concurrently serves as a trustee of the National Museum of Art of Malaysia, a consultant for Nanyang Academy of Fine Arts, and the chief representative of the International Society of Plastic and Audio-Visual Art. He studied both Chinese and Western paintings in his early days, vividly expressing the customs of Southeast Asia, and later entered into Chinese freehand painting, with themes such as figures, flowers and birds, and landscapes. In recent years, he has used semi-abstract techniques to depict the lifestyle of the indigenous people in Southeast Asia. With the flexible use of the "flying" characteristics of calligraphy, he has achieved special insights at figure painting.
1977 The Happy Moments of Grandparents and Grandchildren
1979 The Iban
1980 Let’s Get Really Drunk
1980 Catching Louse
1981 The (Music) Movement
"Min Sheng Bao" reported for three consecutive days (1980/12/19~1980/12/21):
Malaysian Chinese painter Chung Chen Sun will be at the Taipei History Museum tomorrow for his first return-to-China painting exhibition. Chung Chen Sun is known as the most outstanding contemporary Chinese painter and art educator in Malaysia... In 1966, he founded Malaysia's first art college, the Malaysian Institute of Art. Over the past ten years, this art college has cultivated countless art professionals. The Malaysian government has awarded him the honor of serving the country to commend his achievements. The direction of Chung Chen Sun's exploration in art is the concurrent development of Chinese and Western paintings, however, has drastically changed. He has recently switched to the freehand brushwork of Chinese literati, using ink to express the customs of the Southern Countries and the Chinese Zen abstract works.
Kuan Chih-Chung (1931-1995), who was a “Min Sheng Bao" reporter at the time and an avid student of art, used his interview titled "Exploring the Modernization of Chinese Art Painting" (1980/12/24) to position Chung as the creator of modern Chinese painting or modern ink painting. In fact, it also resonated with both Taiwan's Fifth Moon Group and Tong Fang Group's earth-shattering "Modern Chinese Painting Movement" initiative launched in 1957, and the participation of MUSEUM OF HISTORY in the Bienal de São Paulo in Brazil, which produced a unique style of abstract ink painting. However, in the interview, the question of how to abstractify ink painting was not discussed in details, such as the last question:
"What do you think of the future for the modernization of Chinese art painting?" Chung Chen Sun's reply was:
“I am very optimistic! Western artists, like Western thinkers, are facing a period of cultural depression brought about by high-tech civilization. More and more Western scholars and artists are paying more and more attention to the cultural treasure of mankind – Oriental thinking. And we are living in this treasure mountain, should we be afraid that there is no treasure to be found? I'm afraid that if we the people of the Orient "look but do not see", we can't tell the true shape of Lushan because we are in the mountain.”
On the contrary, the view of "advancing with the times" reflects Mr. Chung's faithfulness to his creative feelings and was pretty sincere:
“Basically, I think modern people should exhibit the modern spirit. In other words, I am living out a modern person’s life and thinking which is the driving force for the themes of my art creation...I think that to be a modern painter, one should have extensive modern knowledge, and should no longer only paint one specific thing in his life as an ancient painter did.”
" United Daily News " reporter Chen Changhua also at the same time reported that "Chung Chen Sun had painted two styles of works" had raised the same questions as what Taiwan's ink painting industry concerns: "Many domestic painters had faced the circumstances that: what shall they paint?" How to express 'modern Chinese painting'? It is suggested that Mr. Chung's creation may point a bright path for Taiwan's ink painting artists.
The climax of exchanges appeared six days before the end of the exhibition (1980/12/29). Kuan Chih-Chung planned and hosted a symposium on the "Evaluation Values of Traditional Chinese Painting Art". Participants were: Professor Liu Wen-tan of the Department of Philosophy, National Taiwan University; Professor Lu Ching-Fu and Wang Hsiu-Hsiung of Department of Fine Arts, National Taiwan Normal University; National Taiwan University of Arts Professor Ling Song-lang; Lee Chi-Mao, and Malaysian Chinese painter Chung Chen Sun. It kicked off with the "modernization of Chinese painting" as the main topic, and after the various opinions, a unanimous agreement was reached: not to have culture cringe and don't get stuck with the old traditions, to have an open mind to embrace unification naturally.
In March 1981, the "Traditional Chinese Painting Exhibition from 1975 to 1980" organised by MUSEUM OF HISTORY was exhibited at the Cernuschi Museum in France. Traditional Chinese Ink painter Huang Chun-pi exhibited four paintings, Zhang Da-qian and Chung Chen Sun each exhibited three, Chiu Shan-teng and Chiang Ming- Shyan two paintings each, Chen Chi-kwan exhibited five because the museum considered it to be more modern. The remaining 37 people exhibited one painting each, which also showed Mr. Chung's weight in the art arena. In June, Chung Chen Sun attended the "1st International Symposium on Aesthetics" hosted by Tian Man-shi, head of the Department of Fine Arts of Chinese Cultural University. In August, the large-scale 1st Asian Pacific Conference on Arts Education was held at the National Taiwan Normal University and Principal Chung was one of the invited experts. The other international scholars who participated in the conference were: Dr. Lee Da Yeon, President of Hongik University in South Korea, Eigo Ohuchi, Dean of Nihon University College of Art, Director of the Cultural Center of Philippines Aberno, Professor Sushiben, Srinakharinwirot University in Thailand, Principal Wu Tsung Kan, Nanyang Academy of Fine Arts, Singapore, and Hehua Shi, a researcher in the Australian Music Department; there are four scholars from the United States: Dr. Ford, Dean of the California College of The Arts, Professor Stephens, President of Academy of Art College in San Francisco, Beverly, Dean of the School of Art of San Francisco State University, and Professor Zhuo Yiyu from California State University. At the closing, the "Asia-Pacific Conference on Art Education " was established, with President Wu Tsung Kan and Principal Chung Chen Sun as the deputy vice-chairmen.
The close contacts between Chung Chen Sun and Taiwan had finally "bear the fruit." On October 2, 1981, the Fine Arts Department of Chinese Cultural University invited him to be a visiting professor. Because of this reason, Chen Yung-mo (and later his wife Lin Qiu-fang) of Chinese Cultural University at that time became his disciple. In 2004, Chen held a solo exhibition at MUSEUM OF HISTORY. The then director Huang Kuang-nan gave him the following evaluation: "Lineage of Chung Chen Sun, his brushwork is simple enough, the composition is strange yet natural, and it breaks through all his predecessors." It seemed that he had inherited the style of his teacher. Therefore, the resume in his "Old and New Bamboo Groves" album contained such a remark: "In 1983, Professor Tian Man-shi recommended Mr. Chung Chen Sun to him to learn splash ink figure painting.", and the teacher was also happy to write an inscription for one of the student's albums.
The "International Contemporary Ink Painting Association" was established in July 1982 at the MUSEUM OF HISTORY. In addition to Chung Chen Sun, Malaysian artists also include Le Chek Wen, Tan Tong, and Huang Yao. The participating artists from Taiwan include Shen Yao-Tsu, Ho Huai-shuo, Kuan Chih-Chung, Lee Yih Hong, and Wu Hsueh-Jang; Singapore artists include Chen Wen Hsi, Tan Oe Pang, and Tan Joo Jong; Hong Kong artists include Wucius Wang, Carrie Koo Mei, and Irene Chou; Korean artists include Hong Suk-Chang, Song Soo-nam, and Chʻoe Pyŏng-sik, Guo Dawei from the United States and Pang Hui from Canada. Scholars include Joan Stanley-Baker, Bai Qizhu, and Quan Dezhou. "Hsiung Shih Art Monthly" called it "the largest modern ink painting exhibition in China in recent years with the largest number of participating painters", and published a rather abstract ink painting by Chung. In the forum, his views were more firmed and open:
Ink painting is a medium of expression through painting, not a "patent" of Chinese painting. Of course, since ink painting originated in China and has a long history of a few thousand years, it is naturally related closely to China's social norms, philosophical thoughts, and moral concepts. At present, the study of ink painting is no longer limited to China but includes all parts of the world. However, the purpose of the International Contemporary Ink Painting Association is to pursue the fundamental spiritual connotation of Oriental culture. I think that because of the pursuit of the spirit of Chinese culture, the way of expression should not be too formal. It is alright to paint with a Chinese calligraphy brush, a brush, or even a broom. Because efficiency is the fundamental requirement, all the techniques and methods that can achieve results are worth exploring.
It seemed like the modern ink painting perceived by Chung Chen Sun is not whether it is abstract or not, but to grasp the traditional spirit and use the cross-media and cross-cultural ways to interpret and showcase it, which should be the right direction we must move towards.
For Taiwan's private galleries, Mr. Chung didn't miss out on his presence either. The Tianyan Art Museum, Water Dragon Yin Art Gallery, Celebrity Art Gallery, Spring Art Gallery, Shenlai Gallery, etc. in Taipei also have had his exhibitions and even related reports about his artworks in the market. Some posters just bought back fond memories.
Related reports continued to follow his moves. Renowned art collector Chen Zibin written an article titled "A Painter and an Art Educator - Chung Chen Sun" which was published in the 154th issue of "Hsiung Shih Art Monthly" (December 1983) and although it is only half a page long, I found his comment was quite appropriate:
His ink paintings are not restricted to any rules, a maverick, full of creative spirit, and has opened a brand new era... His brushstrokes are like beyond imagination, elegant, overpowering, and unstoppable... His works have integrated traditional Chinese ink techniques with Western-style and they are modern ink paintings that carry the expression of Eastern thoughts, feelings, and philosophy.
In an article titled "The Interview of Malaysian Chinese painter Mr. Chung Chen Sun's Visit to Motherland" in "Hsiung Shih Art Monthly" Issue 157 (March 1984), apart from introducing his investment in art, it is rare to have him being so open of his cultural identity:
However, due to the differences in history and culture, Chinese painters stayed in their clique for a long time, and they rarely communicated with the Malays. The development of art and culture is almost going in different directions and are restricted by various government regulations, hence they have very little sense of belonging. However, Chung Chen Sun does not agree with the local Chinese community's biased attitude of excessively emphasizing ethnic rights and safeguarding ethnic interests, leading to closed and exclusive, extreme sinicization. While constantly negotiating with the government and fighting for the rights and interests of the Chinese, he advocated that in addition to tracing the traditional culture of the motherland, the Chinese people should also recognize the reality in front of them, so that they can integrate and assimilate the cultural landscape produced in the unique natural environment of the tropical Nanyang. On one hand is to establish self-confidence and a sense of belonging from art creation and yet, on the one hand, to create a local art path that is different from the motherland and the West, so that they can develop a style that truly belongs to them.
This also resonated with his attitude of seeking innovation and change in art creation. In another interview, he said: “I deeply believe that, as a modern Chinese ink painter, one should not always inherit traditional aesthetic concepts and painting models and hide in the ivory tower sheltered by the ancestors. Instead, one should show his or her true temperament and feelings so that traditional Chinese ink paintings can come together with the spiritual life of modern people, breaking through the bottleneck, creating a new form of modern ink painting that is full of contemporary sense.” (160th issue of "Hsiung Shih Art Monthly", June 1984)
Even rarer and honourably, the Chinese Writers & Artists Association awarded him the 25th Chinese Literary Award. He was one of the ten winners. Together with Shi Yingzhou, he won the "Overseas Literary Work Award", which showed that he is highly recognized in the Taiwan art community. Kuan Chih-Chung, who was his die-hard fan, made another report, encouraging him to stick to the path of modern ink painting: “I sincerely hope that Professor Chung Chen Sun and all comrades who are committed in the creation of modern ink painting carry on with a cautious and rigorous attitude, faithfully upholding the consistent creative belief to advance on the road of creation without any expectations and fear. New roads are always lonely and adventurous. In fact, art creation is a kind of spiritual exploration of thoughts, emotions, and forms into the unknown universe. Otherwise, where is the value of art? ── However, as long as you can endure loneliness, hold on to your principles, and can be cruel to yourself to persist on, time will be the best judge.” ("Min Sheng Bao", 1984/6/8)
In fact, his idea of fusing Chinese and Western has never been shaken. At the symposium of the Contemporary Chinese Painting Symposium and Exhibition in Hong Kong, he once said: Chinese painters should not care about whether their creative methods are traditional or modern, but should absorb foreign cultures while maintaining their roots in the tradition and establish a contemporary Chinese painting as historically, Chinese culture has been continuously absorbing foreign cultures. The above-mentioned painters are in fact in favor of integrating tradition with modernity to open a new chapter, but in terms of attitude, they may seem to be separated by having the contradictory opinions of rejecting tradition and maintaining tradition. (In 185th Issue of "Hsiung Shih Art Monthly", July 1986)
Principal Chung continued to become the cultural ambassador for Taiwan and Malaysia. The newly opened Museum of Art (now National Taiwan Museum of Fine Arts) held the 1st Fine Art Exhibition of the Federation of Asian Art Association (1988) and he was one of the representative leaders from overseas, with Huang Chaohu, the chairman of the Taichung Fine Arts Association, Moon Kun, the head of the Daegu Municipal Branch of the Korean Art Association, Niwa Toshio, President of Japan Creative Society, and Thang Kiang How, President of Modern Art Society Singapore. In the ninth exhibition in 1994, China, Japan, South Korea, Indonesia, the Philippines, Malaysia, Macau, Hong Kong, and Singapore exhibited 250 graphic paintings at the National Museum of History. Wang Tiwu, chairman of the United Daily News, presented the horse picture of Chung Chen Sun to Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir at the 23rd Annual Conference of Chinese Language Press Institute. He also made his presence at the International Painting, Calligraphy and Printing Art Exhibition Competition (in 1995) held at National Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall and the Yilan Guizhulin International Art Workshop (2009). "Taiwan Art Yearbook" has it:
Chung Chen Sun (The Drunken Sober Layperson) male, was born in Malacca in 1935. In 1987, he received a master's degree from the College of Professional Studies of the University of San Francisco, specializing in ink painting. He is truly the art ambassador of Taiwan and Malaysia.
He has been recognized as an artist in Taiwan's art history, a "friend of art" (also a "good friend") who is so familiar to us and as close as a family member.
In 2012, 78-year-old Chung Chen Sun and 88-year-old Lee Chi-mao (1925-2019) exhibited at MUSEUM OF HISTORY with "Xunfeng Art Tour", which is a bit like "away from home when young and return home when old", which had been 30 over years since the solo exhibition at Museum of History in 1980. The bamboo calligraphy and painting exhibition at the Buddha Memorial Hall in 2013 should be the end of his artistic footprint in Taiwan. This south wind blowing from Malaysia has been blowing for more than half a century. Not sure if the name "Xunfeng Art Tour"(Summer Breeze from the South Art Tour) is coincidental or intentional? It was a great honor for Taiwan to have known Mr. Chung Chen Sun, and it was a great privilege for the MUSEUM OF HISTORY to exhibit Principal Chung’s oeuvre many times over! I believe his confidant Kuan Chih-Chung and his best friend Lee Chi-mao who are in Heaven now should also be nodding their heads in agreement.
1 Kinichiro Ishikawa, 1929, "Xunfeng Couch", translated by Yan Juanying, 2001, "Scenery and Mood: A Guide to Taiwan Modern Art Literature", Taipei: Lion Art, p. 134.
2 His teacher Chen Wen Hsi exhibited more than 90 oeuvres at MUSEUM OF HISTORY on October 18, 1980, two months earlier than him. MUSEUM OF HISTORY has "A Shrewdness of Apes Painting" and "A Flock of Roosters Painting" in its collection. Chen also participated in the "I Love Plum Blossom" exhibition in 1981 and the International Contemporary Ink Painting Exhibition in 1982 (with Tan Oe Pang and Tan Joo Jong as Singapore representatives).
3 Kuan Chih-Chung, formerly known as Zhao Ji, came to Taiwan to study in the Art Department of the Fu Hsing Kang College and studied Western painting theory under Li Chung-Sheng. He was a reporter at Oriental Daily News, China Daily News, and Min Sheng Bao. In 1995, he went to South Korea to participate in the 1st Gwangju Biennale (the theme was "The Oriental Spirit of Literati Painting"). He was the only representative of Taiwan (Chung Chen Sun also participated in this exhibition at the time). Unfortunately, he passed away due to asthma. The following year, MUSEUM OF HISTORY held for him " Wu xiang zhi xiang (Formless Images)- Kuan Chih-Chung Memorial Exhibition".
4 Liao Hsin-tien, 2019, "The "Orient" Monotype - The Revolution of Brush and Ink in the "Modern Chinese Painting Movement" in Taiwan after the Second World War", "Landscape and Circulation: The Construction of Taiwan Fine Arts". Tainan: Tainan City Art Museum, pages 219-257. See also the other works by the author, "The Process of "Re-Orientalization" of Taiwanese Fine Arts after WW2, Keynote Speech at the 2018 Congress of the International Academy of Ceramics", “Historical Relics” 299: 6-11.
5 According to the stroke order of surname: Huang Yau Chun, Wang Guo-he, Wang Zhenxi, He Huaishuo, Wu Hsueh-Jang, Lee Chi-mao, Li Chun-chi, Li Chung-Chung, Li Lung-shou, Chou Chen, Lin Chang-Te, Lin Jin-zhong/Lin Chin-Chung, Chiu Ding-Fu, Hung Ken-shen, Fan Po-Hung, Tu Tsan-lin, Yuan Chin-Taa, Zhang Shen-xi, Zhang Songnian, Chen Jiou-chuan, Chen Dachuan, Chen Ming-Hsien, Huang Yun-chuan, Huang Cai Song, Wong Lui Sang, Chu Shan-Ching, Liu Ping-heng, Lio Ko-sung/ Liu Kuo-sung, Au Ho-Nien, Tsai Yu, Tsai Mau-sung, Deng Syue-fong, Cheng Yet-Por, Cheng Shan-hsi, Hsueh Ching-mao, Xie Shuiji, Lo Cheng-Hsien.
6 The rest of the winners are all respected masters in Taiwan’s art and literature circles: photography award Long Chin-San, essay award Su Hsüeh-lin, Chinese painting award Huang Chun-pi, novel award Hsieh Ping-ying, dance award He Zhi-Hao, soundtrack award Hou Yu-Tsung, national drama award Wang Fu-sheng, film award George Wang Chueh.